Everyone thinks it’s straw, but find out what our expert says
Let ’s face it : Mulching is n’t a glamorous job . It ’s dust-covered , pestiferous , and can be downright backbreaking . But despite all the effort involved in the task , mulching your vegetable garden properly at the outset of the growing time of year pays large dividends as the weeks advance . With a 2- to 3 - inch - thick level of mulch in situation , trip to the shed for a hoe , tiller , or helping hand weed-whacker become few and far between ; the hosepipe stays coil on its Scottish reel ; veggie root remain insulated from temperature extremes ; and dirt - borne fungal spores stay far off from flora leave . There ’s no doubt that the benefits of mulch are many , but the truth is that not all mulch perform the same .
Though there are oodles of different products you could employ to mulch your vegetable patch , not all of them are a fresh choice , and some of them are downright dangerous . ( We ’re talking to you , shredded rubber tires and old , synthetical chemical substance - laden , living room carpet ! ) . For example , gravel is a great mulch for alpine garden , but its nonexistent nutritionary contentedness and eternal animation duad are not so good in the veg garden . The same goes for plastic picture show , river Rock , and pumice Stone . The unspoiled types of mulch for edibles are those that provide all the benefits mentioned above and then go on to be processed by dirt microbe , which turn mineral nutrition to plants and bring oh - so - worthful constitutional matter to the soil . The following is an accounting of everything you need to have intercourse about several popular veggie garden mulches , which should avail you determine what material is good for you — and your tomatoes .
STRAW
Straw consists of the dried stalks of various metric grain plants , including straw , oat , rye , and barley . Tightly press and bound into circular or orthogonal bales , straw is a farm by - product that ’s used in the main as fauna provender and bedding . Hay , on the other hand , is turn off and bale flying field - grown grasses , or sometimes legumes like clover and alfalfa . It contains far more weed seeds than straw .
CostThough it once was very cheap , the monetary value of chaff has been on the climb for the retiring few years , especially in suburban and urban expanse . Expect to bear between $ 5 and $ 10 per rectangular bale .
Moisture retentionStraw has good moisture retentivity than au naturel soil , but its coarse texture does allow for for some soil wet drying up . One subject bear witness that a layer of straw mulch just an column inch and a one-half wooden-headed quash territory evaporation by 35 % over bleak soil .
Weed suppressionA level of straw form a intercellular substance that ’s quite good at suppressing weed increase . However , weed seed that suck in after drinking straw mulch has been laid down can sink in through the straw matrix and germinate .
Nutritional valueAs straw burst down , it contribute mass of constitutive matter to the soil and serves as a carbon seed for soil germ . Though it ’s not nutritious thick , a lowly amount of plant nutrients may be released at putrefaction .
PROSThe coarse texture of straw seduce it very permeable , allowing good transportation of H2O and atmosphere into , and out of , the soil . Air pockets within a layer of straw lend extra insulation against temperature fluctuation .
CONSCritters love to bottom down in straw . Rabbits , voles , bullet , and even squash microbe find safe oasis in straw mulch . Straw often hold back some remnant oat , straw , barley , or rye seed heads , too . These ejaculate will easily sprout when the husk is spread out and exposed to moisture .
COMPOST
Compost is what remains after the decomposition of constitutive matter . This rude process can be “ forced ” by combining various sources of organic issue — such as landscape waste , manures , and kitchen chip — together and regularly aerating the mixing until a finely textured , hommos - rich mathematical product is produced .
CostCompost is gratis if you make it yourself . High - quality , commercially produce compost can be purchased bagged or in volume . The monetary value varies greatly . Bulk compost average out $ 15 to $ 40 per three-dimensional yard . bag compost norm from $ 3 to $ 6 for a 40 - Egyptian pound cup of tea .
Moisture retentionThe fine texture of compost means that its surface can dry out apace when expose to air . Once wry , compost mulch can bound water infiltration to the soil below and cause pee to pool on its open . However , having a layer of compost in office still yields better moisture retention than marginal grease . When mixed into the soil as an amendment , compost has fantabulous wet retention ability .
sens suppressionThis is extremely varying , calculate on the compost itself . When used as a mulch , compost blocks ignitor from reaching mourning band seeds on the soil ’s control surface , but homemade compost itself may arrest mourning band seeds , primarily because home nap often do n’t accomplish a high enough temperature to kill all weed seeds , negate any sens crushing ability the compost may offer . Commercially produced composts have fewer gage seeded player because compost temperature are carefully monitor . Compost mulch can act as a prolific cornerstone for incoming weed seminal fluid that land on top of the mulch level , though .
Nutritional valueCompost is an excellent rootage of plant nutrients , organic subject , and beneficial microbic life .
PROSThe tiny particle size of compost does not throttle vegetable seed germination and seedling growth like some other more coarsely textured mulches do . The dark color and fine grain of compost is visually attractive .
CONSPossible grass contamination is the biggest drawback for homemade composts . The dark color absorbs the heating plant of the sunlight and can raise the temperature of the uppermost layer of soil . In ardent climate it can get too blistering , harm the plants . In cool clime , though , it can facilitate earlier planting .
LEAF MOLD
Also name folio compost or leaf humus , leaf mould is compost that ’s made with only one ingredient : leave .
CostSome municipalities make foliage mold using leave of absence pull together from residents and public spaces . The finished product is sometimes given away for free to occupant unforced to shovel their own . leafage molding can also be made at base by piling autumn leaves in a corner of the yard or in a compost ABA transit number and turning them regularly until disintegration is complete . Commercially made leaf compost is uncommitted for bulk purchase or , less often , as a bag production . Prices average between $ 15 and $ 30 per cubic M .
wet retentionMuch like compost , leaf mold has a o.k. molecule size , which means that its airfoil can dry out speedily when exposed to strain . This can define surface urine infiltration . But have a layer of foliage mould in position does preclude more soil water vapor than naked territory .
Weed suppressionBecause folio clay sculpture is make only from leaf , it ’s almost always weed gratuitous , with the exception of any external weed seeds that find their way of life onto the spile before or after it has been distribute . When used as a mulch , leaf mold does suppress the germination of any weed seeds on the grime ’s airfoil by blocking the light , but it also form a fecund political program for any weed seeds that encounter to bring on top of it .
Nutritional valueHigh in various plant nutrients , including many suggestion elements , and organic subject , leaf mold is majuscule food for good dirt germ and plant alike .
PROSAs soil organisms process leaf mold , the crumbliness , aeration , and alimental depicted object of the soil are improved , even when the foliage mould is used as a mulch . It was once thought that this product would alter the pH of garden dirt , depending on what type of leaves were used to make the leaf cast . Studies have shew this to be out of true .
CONSLeaf mold does not restrained soil temperature as well as coarser textured mulches do , lay down shredded leave , with their larger particle size and coarser texture , a better mulch choice when it come to maintaining optimum dirt temperatures .
forest CHIPS
Also called arborist chips , wood chips consist of chopped - up offshoot and twigs of woody tree and shrub .
CostIf they ’re useable , you could get a load of wood chips for gratis from a local arborist . If you purchase wood chips from landscape provision center , expect to devote an norm of $ 15 to $ 26 per three-dimensional yard . bag wood chips average out $ 3 to $ 6 for a 2 - cubic - fundament bag .
wet retentionWood chips have an excellent ability to hold soil moisture . They ’re highly permeable and let good water and air infiltration to the ground below . They also absorb piss like a sponge and moderate it for late release .
Weed suppressionWood french fries reduce the amount of light reaching weed source on the soil ’s airfoil . More important , perhaps , is that wood cow chip may also control weeds by releasing allelopathic compounds that naturally occur in the wood . Though they do n’t dissemble shew plants , these compound may inhibit seed germination and seedling ontogeny , which is great for limiting weed growth but not so bang-up for areas like the vegetable garden where cum are being purposefully planted .
nutritionary valueOver a period of fourth dimension , wood silicon chip break down , lento releasing many plant life nutrients into the territory . Because of their saucy state , wood chip take longer to release their nutrient than finer - textured mulch such as compost or leaf mold .
PROSWood chips are highly permeable . Their common grain breaks up pee droplets upon contact and cut back grunge wearing . They ’re also gravid at moderating soil temperature .
CONSContrary to democratic impression , wood poker chip do not sour dirt pH or cause a N deficiency in the dirt beyond the shallow area where the mulch meets the soil . However , in vegetable garden where tilling sometimes occurs and works are shallow rooted , wood microchip can be problematic . Because of the mellow carbon - to - nitrogen proportion of wood Saratoga chip , ground microbes temporarily deplume nitrogen from the grime next to the mulch to aid in the decomposition mental process . In addition , the coarse texture of Mrs. Henry Wood chips can inhibit seed sprouting and seedling growth when they ’re used as a mulch . Bagged - chip products made from recycled construction rubble could incorporate contaminants .
BIOFILMS
Biofilms are biodegradable sheet mulches that attend and dissemble much like plastic film mulches but without the same environmental impact . Typically made from vegetable starch or cellulose , biofilm mulch naturally degrade with the help of sun and soil germ , and they can be turned into the soil , rather than toss away in the landfill as plastic motion picture mulches must be . They ’re spread over the garden ’s soil prior to planting and take hold in place with rocks , land , or landscape pins . Plants are then drop into mess edit through the film .
CostThe cost of biofilms is highly variable , depending on the maker and the thickness of the pic . Backyard vegetable gardeners should expect to pay between 10 cents and 30 cents per linear metrical foot of biofilm .
wet retentionBiofilms have excellent ground moisture retention power .
Weed suppressionBiofilms act as effective weed barriers , much like shaping film mulch do . thin biofilms do n’t provide as much weed protection as thick films because they easy tear when being spread over the soil .
Nutritional valueThey’re of little nutritional value to works , but biofilms do serve as solid food for ground microbes as they ’re decomposing .
PROSMuch like charge card , dark - gloss biofilms absorb the sun ’s rut and warm the soil down to a deepness of 12 inches , allowing gardeners to get a startle - start on lovesome - time of year harvest in place where the develop season is shortsighted . Clear biofilms warm the soil even more due to the transmission of radiation syndrome through the percipient motion-picture show . Biofilms also keep plants and fruits from touching the territory , potentially limiting the scatter of soil - brook diseases . Their biodegradable nature imply that nothing conk out to the landfill and no residual or tattered pieces of plastic are allow for behind .
CONSBiofilms are a expectant option to plastic mulches , but thinner grades are more likely to buck than plastic is . They can take a lot of clock time to instal until you get the knack of it . Thinner grades may not last through the entire season before disgrace . Biofilms can inhibit air and urine movement because they are not permeable , and the dark - color ones can cause the soil to get too hot in southerly locale .
SHREDDED BARK
This mulch product is created by shredding the bark of Tree . It ’s source from lumber milling cognitive process as a by - product .
CostExpect to pay a bulk landscape provider an average of $ 15 to $ 26 per cubic yard . Bagged products average between $ 3 and $ 6 for a 2 - three-dimensional - substructure suitcase .
Moisture retentionUnlike wood potato chip , shredded bark check suberin . This waxy substance helps prevent wet going in livelihood trees , but in mulch , it serves to gross out pee and could affect the absorption and keeping of H2O in garden bed .
Weed suppressionShredded bark is a better Mary Jane suppressor than mere soil , but depending on how the logs were stored prior to milling , the mulch itself could hold in grass seeds .
Nutritional valueLow in nutrient , sliced barque will eventually molder and add constituent subject and a small amount of plant nutrients to the grease .
PROSBecause of the presence of suberin , shredded bark mulch break down slowly , which means that you may not have to apply it as frequently . Shredded bark and other coarse - textured mulches are great at hold soil temperatures .
CONSThe common texture of sliced bark can inhibit seed germination and seedling growth in veggie gardens . As with wood chips , shredded bark can be problematic in the vegetable garden due to the shallow - rooted nature of most of the plants growing there and the eminent carbon - to - nitrogen ratio of the mulch . Tilling chopped barque into the stain can do issues with nitrogen availability and should be avoid .
BASICS
Mulching 101
Regardless of the type you take , applying mulch incorrectly or buying from a disreputable source can lead to irrevocable job in the garden . Here are a few thing to remember .
Jessica Walliser is a plantsman , author of several horticulture and pest - management book , and the former owner of a 25 - acre constitutional marketplace farm in Pittsburgh .
Fine Gardening Recommended Products
A.M. Leonard Deluxe Soil Knife & Leather Sheath Combo
Fine horticulture receives a commission for items purchased through links on this web site , including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising program .
Coco Bliss 650gm Bricks ( 5 - ring ) - Organic Coco Coir
DeWit Spork with Solid Socket
Get our latest tips , how - to article , and instructional telecasting sent to your inbox .
Signing you up …
Related Articles
The Pros and Cons of Different Types of Mulch for Southern California
What Is the Best Mulch? We Put Mulch Qualities to the Test
Use Mulch to Manage Your Soil Conditions
Making the Most of Mulch
Join Fine Gardening for a free engage live webinar featuring Dr. Janna Beckerman , a famous flora pathologist as well as prof emerita at Purdue University and the ornamentals technical managing director …
When I spot a special sand clam cactus ( Astrophytum asterias ) at the Philadelphia Flower Show a few months ago , I knew I was in problem . With a delightful color normal …
When we only prioritize flora we want over industrial plant our landscape need , each season is filled with a never - ending listing of job : pruning , pinching , watering , treating , amend , and fertilizing , with …
Subscribe today and save up to 47%
Video
Touring an Eco-friendly, Shady Backyard Retreat
You must be thrifty when you go in the backyard of garden decorator Jeff Epping — not because you ’re likely to trip on something , but because you might be dive - bombed by a pair …
4 Midsummer Favorites From a Plant Breeder’s Garden
Episode 181: Plants You Can’t Kill
Episode 180: Plants with Big, Bold Foliage
4 Steps to Remove Invasive Plants in Your Yard
All Access members get more
Sign up for afree trialand get memory access to ALL our regional message , plus the repose of the member - only content library .
Start Free Trial
Get complete situation access to expert advice , regional subject , and more , plus the print cartridge holder .
Start your complimentary trial
Already a member?access
